I think the template with the base area marked out will help a lot. You really can't get more clear than "your base should fill out this area, not much less and not much more," with a lovely blue box showing the boundaries.

If we can't understand those simple instructions, we fail at reading comprehension.

Firn, my intention isn't to push the rules, I read this thread more times to try to understand all (always because of the language). But when I tried the image that you putted to see the proportions on my last cats base I saw that this was out, and they all were accepted, so I thought that you could saw it different for different bases. Because I still had some doubt I asked on the other thread, and they said "yes, they should go". I also thought that they had to have at least almost the same margin at each side, which I did. BUT I still had some doubt, for this I wrote here too, before finish the work and maybe (now it is sure) force you to reject them. I have to admit that I think that this rule is a bit strict, not because I don't agree that knuffel have to have almost the same proporction, but because the weight so strict is a big limit for different bases. Obviously this is your site, so it's on you to decide I'll try to change the bases to make them fit as much as possible on your image.
Thank you for your answer


EDIT: ml1201, you can see how they'll become in my spoiler thread

Firn wrote:Do you have any tips for me to make it more understandable? Like, what kind of text or images would you have needed there to understand what I tried to explain to you? Or is it maybe still not understandable?
I really do not know how to explain it better with words and illustrations than I already did..

It seems to me that a lot of people are having problems making their knuffle bases proportional to the bases given on the site. (I know I pestered you enough with my own questions.) I think it would probably be best to show the overlay pictures (such as my cat base and the original knuffle base) as an example when you state that the knuffles need to proportional. You should also state that the "head and feet" of the knuffles need to approximately reach the same size as the original knuffle base. So things like ears, hair, hats, etc do not count. I know that confused me for a while because I was counting the height of my cat's ears as part of it's overall head size.

Okay...someone's gotta tell me what's wrong with my knuffel...T^T I want him made...idk why he's getting rejected...I figure its the horns which I'm shortening...but is there something else? (you can see the designs in my gallery)

This was the only reason I got ._.

At least one of the image files is drawn out of proportions.

Ah, let me see then. I used the one from your da earlier so didn't see size of actual knuffel.