Page 25 of 144
Re: Why was my Wild Knuffel rejected?
Posted: May 16th, '12, 06:41
by Wolltiger
I guess it is not the glow but the "clothes".
Third stage: snake-like bondages/stuff
-> forth stage: dress... but.. HOW?!
It looks like randomly taking away some stuff and adding some others and that isnt allowed.
EDIT:
Same with the hair, she just looks completely like another person from 3rd to 4th stage...
Re: Why was my Wild Knuffel rejected?
Posted: May 16th, '12, 08:57
by Firn
Since no one hit the nail I would like to add that this Knuffel also doesn't really show significant changes in all stages. If you looked at one stage, covering the others, and then, after a few minutes just looked at the next, you would probably not be able to tell the difference.
And, in addition to that, that there is no real evolution: The Knuffel doesn't change from something into something else. Girl with blue sash -> girl with blue dress is all you get, but that's not really an evolution.
This is more a general remark, not only towards the last Knuffel posted here:
Unfortunately a lot of Knuffel have basically no concept behind them. Even if they change, there is no evolution, they don't become anything, expect a version of what they were in the beginning with just more clothes.
Evolution would be Girl/boy -> pirate, Girl/boy -> cat, Girl/boy -> Angel, Girl/boy -> Cow, Girl/boy -> Clown, Girl/boy -> Butterfly, Girl/boy -> Astronaut, etc.
I know that after a while it gets difficult to come up with a concept, especially if you have to make 70+ Knuffel like I have. Then some concepts might lack originality. But with wilds no one is forcing you to make them within a certain time frame. You can take all the time you need to come up with a cool, original concept, so take the time you need, especially the people who feel the need to make a new Knuffel every 3 days. Save your ideas and put them into one good Knuffel instead of 10 without a real concept. Just playing "dress up" is not the idea of Knuffel.
Re: Why was my Wild Knuffel rejected?
Posted: May 16th, '12, 11:29
by Alexis
Okay, thanks everyone. I'll probably keep her back and try and sort her out while I make some others. At least I know where I was going wrong.
Re: Why was my Wild Knuffel rejected?
Posted: May 16th, '12, 13:02
by Anored
Re: Why was my Wild Knuffel rejected?
Posted: May 16th, '12, 13:24
by Wiltherel
Well, one reason is that the outline has some pixels floating.
And I think stage 4 and 5 seem a little bit to similar to each other. Same as 2 and 3.
Re: Why was my Wild Knuffel rejected?
Posted: May 16th, '12, 14:19
by Anored
Wiltherel, thanks!
Re: Why was my Wild Knuffel rejected?
Posted: May 18th, '12, 04:18
by Eruvandir
Help me please >.<
It says "At least one of the image files is drawn out of proportions"
images removed
I already resized them so that they're as tall as the knuffel bases that Firn gave ...
Re: Why was my Wild Knuffel rejected?
Posted: May 18th, '12, 04:49
by nectaroustheine
I think that just means that it's too tall for the size of the image. It has to be a certain size within the image, like in the examples on the wild knuffel page.
Re: Why was my Wild Knuffel rejected?
Posted: May 18th, '12, 05:16
by Eruvandir
The ones I made are as tall as the knuffel in that pic with the check mark ... I checked ...
Hmmm ... Maybe I'll check again ...
edit: Okay, one was smaller. I'll go try again ...
Thanks =)
edit 2: I still don't get it ... She got rejected again ...
Is it because she's thin? Is she too thin or too long? O.o
This is her base:
Re: Why was my Wild Knuffel rejected?
Posted: May 18th, '12, 09:55
by qt stripes
elaine3305 wrote:The ones I made are as tall as the knuffel in that pic with the check mark ... I checked ...
Hmmm ... Maybe I'll check again ...
edit: Okay, one was smaller. I'll go try again ...
Thanks =)
edit 2: I still don't get it ... She got rejected again ...
Is it because she's thin? Is she too thin or too long? O.o
This is her base:
It looks quite big/tall. How big is your whole canvas size itself?
