Kingdom of Knuffel

Awesome entries, can't wait to welcome the new NPC to the family
Good luck to the participants!

Soooo many good entry.

I realize it's a bit late to be asking this since I just finished voting, but oh well.
Were we supposed to judge based on the artwork and quality or based on the character and how much we'd like them as a new NPC?
Curious cause I voted based on Character rather than the art skills.

Themis wrote:I realize it's a bit late to be asking this since I just finished voting, but oh well.
Were we supposed to judge based on the artwork and quality or based on the character and how much we'd like them as a new NPC?
Curious cause I voted based on Character rather than the art skills.

Firn said that the contest is based more on design as opposed to the quality, so you are correct!

Some of the entries rocked me. Can't wait to see the result!

Themis wrote:I realize it's a bit late to be asking this since I just finished voting, but oh well.
Were we supposed to judge based on the artwork and quality or based on the character and how much we'd like them as a new NPC?
Curious cause I voted based on Character rather than the art skills.

Don't worry Themis, I did that too. I pictured the character if the design would work as a shop keeper. And there are some really amazing artworks in there but I couldn't feel the shop keeper vibe so I had couldn't vote 5 for it. :c


Also this might be a little silly and lame but I kind of ship the two steampunk entries LOL. orz

Ciel-Kun wrote:

Themis wrote: Also this might be a little silly and lame but I kind of ship the two steampunk entries LOL. orz[/size][/color]

Eheheeh. I like that.

Finally done voting

I also voted on the character design, not the artistic skills.
Some entries are wonderfully drawn but, well, I don't see them as NPCs at all.
On the other hand others had a cute funny concept which I would not hesitate to consider a great shop keeper, and since I assume that they will be re-drawn to match the other NPCs style I don't see any reason to not give them the highest scores.

Amura wrote:Finally done voting

I also voted on the character design, not the artistic skills.
Some entries are wonderfully drawn but, well, I don't see them as NPCs at all.
On the other hand others had a cute funny concept which I would not hesitate to consider a great shop keeper, and since I assume that they will be re-drawn to match the other NPCs style I don't see any reason to not give them the highest scores.

Exactly. Some of the best drawn ones had the more generic concepts, whereas the ones I voted for had some major originality and I liked that.