From what I noticed: your first guy is more constant with adding stuff. There is not much evolution in clothes, but his hair, beard and skin nicely catches up for it. From stage to stage beard is growing visibly longer, hair getting longer and puffier, etc.
Now with the rejected one there is lot of reductions: you add chest and body hair to second stage but take them away totally in third which isn't evolution, beard starts short, grows in second stage, then gets reduced in third, just to grow again in fifth. Again, doesn't count as evolution.