Kingdom of Knuffel

Anime, because it's sweet and very nicely color-balanced.

Both are great, but I'm going with Amura for the unique color combo!

Amura
I just like the flow of colors more, very subtle and nice

Julie ... for unique color match

Close but I'll go with Metea

Metea, I love how the avi pops against the background!

Moon Star. It looks demonic and I like the colors used.

Moon Star as well. The colors are really interesting

This is really really difficult.
Both go for the classic Halloween vibe, have a nice composition, curtains and all (which I'm loving in these avatars).
I would not know which one to choose, maybe I'm going with Rubie's cause I don't see those eyes used that often anymore.

Both are cool, but I really like Amura's color combo.