I loved watching Sailor Moon when I was little, so maybe I'll give this series a shot in the future! I've been meaning to watch Madoka Magica, but I've never got around to doing this.

(Somehow I was reminded of .Hack by the "ability to grant players a 1 in 10,000 chance to become a real life Magical Girl". )

Welp. I know what I'm going to be checking out asap.

I really want to start watching this one! I've watched the first episode, so hopefully I can get further soon.

I'm not a huge fan of the magical girl genre, but I really like all the anime you've mentioned above and I watch something like this from time to time. So I've seen this anime some time ago.

I did like it, but I didn't enjoy it too much. It was because there was one character that I really didn't like and actually it was... A main heroine
She was way too passive for my liking for the most of the show.

I also liked how brutal it was, but it didn't put too much of an impact, since Madoka was first. And I think the whole brutality was set up more nicely in Madoka. I've really, really liked it.

Still, I enjoyed this anime. And I think anyone who likes magical girls and enjoyed Madokaw would like this too.