yeyeah I do kinda see where you're coming from though. Everything has flaws and I guess HP is just one of those things that so many people love so they don't even really take notice of it's flaws because all their focus is just on what they love about it.
I think the story is just so complex and it's cool how it matures as the characters do, at least that's how I feel about the movies, I can't judge the books... yet..

but I constantly hear they're very very good. Oh! And i'm excited for peeves! He was a fun character in the computer games.